An Outstanding Concert by Sanjay Subrahmanyam

Image

I was really fortunate to listen to a 3 1/2 hour of exhilarating music by Sanjay Subramanyan (SS) and team at Bharat Kalachar this evening.   His stenorian voice is still ringing in my ears as i am writing this review.  The way he navigated through the stayis was remarkable and he made even the toughest sangathis look very simple & easy.  He was excellently matched on the violin by Nagai Muralidharan and on the percussion by Tanjavur Ramdas on mridangam and Trichy Murali on the ghatam.  

I understand that he started the concert with a Varnam & I came in when he had just begun the Patnam Subramania Iyer Krithi in Saurashtra “Ninnu joochu” .  Even so early in the concert, his voice had a fine ‘பிசிறு’ that became better and better as the concert progressed.

Since the day was Tuesday, SS rendered “அங்காரகம் ஆஷ்ரயாம்யஹம்’ by Dikshitar in the ragam Surati.  I had learnt this kriti from my grandmother (my first music teacher) who in turn learnt it from Dr S Ramanathan. I could listen to a different ‘பாடாந்தரம்’ when SS sang.  He sang a brief neraval at “தீன ரக்‌ஷ்கம்’ and completed with kalpana swaras.

With his next item, SS left almost everyone wondering about the raga. Trying to place the raga, I was unable to enjoy the intricate alapanai both by the vocalist and the violinist  The suspense was over when he started the kriti “Evarikai” and those who had the lyric books raced to find the raga and one of my neighbours truimphantly whispered ‘Devamanohari’.  Trying to figure out this raga, I did some search using my phone and came across a interesting news that the audience in Ernakulam were equally unable to place Devamanohari during a concert by Sangita Sivakumar in 2005.  Looks like the raga invokes the rasa of suspense!!  For those rasikas who are technically oriented, here is a detailed comparison between Vanaspati and Devamanohari.

SS continued with his masterly concert with yet another piece that left the rasikas active and at the same time wondering. It was சிவசிதம்பரமே  by முத்து தாண்டவர்  in the ragam நாகஸ்வராளி.  It seems that this is quite a regular piece in his concerts as revealed by a quick google search.  When he started, it sounded like Bahudhari but I was not off the mark by a wide margin as both these ragas have some strong similarities.  

பஜரே ரே மானஸ by Mysore Vasudevachariar in Abheri @ Karnataka Devagandhari was next.  Sanjay himself has written a blog post on the confusion about this nomenclature specifically Abheri, Beemplas and Karnataka Devagandhari here. After a detailed ஆலாபனை SS sang the kriti followed by a flurry of kalpanaswaras ending in the தனி ஆவர்த்தனம்.  It was really gratifying to see the majority of the audience staying put and enjoying the the percussion ensemble unlike the exodus to the canteen that is a common occurrence.  

Dikshitar’s Soundararajam Aashraye in Brindavana Saranga (which incidentally had the name of the ragam in the pallavi itself) was rendered at a slower pace in keeping with the identity of the ragam. Sanjay’s diction was excellent.

After a brief appreciation of the artists by Mrs YGP where she likened Sanjay to a trapeze artist doing magic with his voice, Sanjay started an elaborate Ragam Tanam Pallavi. in (what i think as) Simhendra Madhyamam.  While the ஆலாபனை left the audience wondering at times, his Tanam was remarkable.  I wish i had the prowess of Adisesha to describe the amazing journey that he took us during the thanam and it was all the more beautiful because of the violinist who played truly in a scintillating manner.  The pallavi went தாம் தாம் தமது என மமதை இல்லாமலே சத்திய தொண்டு செய்வோம் and Sanjay did full justice to the pallavi.  The atmosphere became more electric in the kalpanaswaras when he added a ராகமாலிகை consisting of ஆனந்தபைரவி, நீலாம்பரி & பூபாளம்.  It would be an understatement to say that SS & Nagai Muralidharan gave us the nectar of these 3 ragas in this phase.

As if adding more honey to an already sweet dish, SS started another ராகமாலிகை in praise of Lord Rama in தமிழ் as a தாலாட்டு using Bouli (or is it Boopalam? I often get confused), Bilahari, Shanmugapriya and another raga that I did not correctly identify.  

It was already past 9 pm and SS has been performing for 3 hours now but he showed no signs of slowing down.  He sang a Swati Tirunal piece in the Ragam பாகேஷ்வரி  and just when we were getting ready to leave he started a விருத்தம் in காம்போதி majestically in a full-throated voice.  This was about Lord Siva in different kshetrams like Thiruperunthurai, Thiruvotriyur, Thiruvaroor and on completing the vritham SS sang காண வேண்டாமோ? by பாபநாசம் சிவன் in Sri Ranjani.  The lyrics were powerful and SS added luster through his rendition.

As a concluding piece SS sang மனமே கணமும் மறவாதே which was first rendered by MS acting as Naradhar in the movie Savithri but my mind went to the time I listened to this by DKJ in a recording.

With pavamaana, SS rang down the curtains of a 31/2 hour concert that left the listeners gasping in admiration and awe.  If I am forced to use only one word to describe the concert it would be “Outstanding”.  

My prayers that Sanjay and the other artists live long to continue to enthrall the listeners world over.  God Bless

(Disclaimer:  The names of the kritis and ragas are to the best of my ability.  If there are any errors, I am willing to correct them)

 

A (H)amsama Concert

This morning (15th Dec 2013), I went to the Russian Cultural Centre to listen to a trans-continental  (my description) fusion music of Anil Srinivasan on the Piano, Sikkil Gurucharan on the vocals rendering carnatic music and Sekar on the Cello.

Why Trans-Continental? Piano and Cello are instruments of European origin (and so is Violin), the vocal music was Carnatic, the percussionist being a tabla player, hence Hindustani and they also played ‘Swan Lake’ of Tchaikovsky (of Russia).

Image

The underlying theme was ‘Swan’ from beginning to end. Let’s now get to the concert.

The first was ‘Swan Lake’ of Tchaikovsky interspersed with the memorable ‘katrilinele varum geetham’ rendered so soulfully by Anil and Sekar.  Very soothing and calm.  I guess that Tchaikovsky had some influence on Ilayaraja because i could hear strains of Raja’s BGM while listening to Swan Lake.

Due to a commotion with a lady trying to get into the row (where I was seated at the end) and asking me ‘when did the concert begin?’, I could not follow Anil’s introduction to the next piece nor could i enjoy it.  Part of the game, I guess.  Thankfully, I did not hear even one mobile ringtone!! Either our audience have become so sensitive and hence put it on silent mode or there were no calls to anyone, being a sunday morning!!

It was time for Sikkil Gurucharan’s (SG) entree and Sekar left the stage (to join later).  Here is where Anil elaborated on the ‘Swan’ on different dimensions and how it resembles human potential.  When he made the connection of great people being called ‘ParamaHamsa’, there was a genuine and spontaneous appreciation from the audience.

The piece started with a verse from Vedanta Desikar’s ‘Hamsa Sandesham’ and then went on to Thygrajar’s immortal ‘Sujana jeevana’ in Harikhamboji.  Although Anil and SG have been performing together for 7 years now, I have never heard them and hence was quite curious how a piano will fare as a co-player (would not like to call it as an accompanist) in a carnatic music.  I must say that i was pleasantly surprised and even delighted given the tonality that is so inherent of the piano and Anil’s playing.  Was reminded of Vellore Ramabhadran’s accompaniments which used to be like caressing and flowing with the vocal music.

The next item really posed some challenges to me. It was a Ragam Thanam Pallavi (as it unfurled) and the artists really had me guessing about the Raga.  When Anil began, I thought it was Dharmavathi but as it moved on, I was confused because i thought i heard some different notes as well.  It was in the Thanam that both Anil and SG excelled with a Ragamalika.  I have often heard ragamalikas in the kalpana swaras post the pallavi and it was the first time i was hearing it at the thanam stage itself.  I was delighted as many in the audience by the seamless transition from Dharmavathi to Vasantha (am still awaiting Anil’s confirmation on that) to Hamsanadham to Hamsadhwani and i also thought i heard Hamsanandi.  I am not sure if they rendered the swarams in the same order though!

The pallavi went “Kesavam Madhavam Vasudevam – Gopika vallabham Bhaje” in Simhendra Madhyamam (an almost neighbouring raga to Dharmavathi).  I was perplexed by the choice of the tabla as the percussion instrument in a carnatic western music concert but the outcome was great.  The tabla player Jagjeeth really played in close consonance to the main players.  The kalpana swarams were equally mesmerising.

I was surprised about the selection of Andal’s ‘Chitram chiru kaale’ in Madhyamavathi at this juncture because Madhyamavathi is sung at the end of the concerts traditionally and wondered whether the concert was getting over.  Thankfully, it was not to be as Sekar joined the other two in rendering Lalgudi Jayaraman’s Desh Tillana sans the percussion support.  Sekar’s Desh was really moving and brought out the essence of the raga.  It was wonderful listening to the three players in unison.

Next was an arrangement in the ragam Suddha Saveri by legendary violinist VS Narasimhan that was followed by a rendition of Kulasekara Azhwar’s Pasuram (the first part of the famous ‘pavazha vaai kaanbene’ on Tiruvengadamudaiyan).  I could see how Ilayaraaja had brought out the essence of the Suddha Saveri raga in his ‘kadhal mayakkam’ song from the movie ‘Pudhumai penn’.

Anil brought the concert to a close and  thanked everybody for being there, when my friend Ramesh shouted from the audience asking for one more composition.  When this snowballed into a huge demand, Anil gracefully accepted and the artists rendered the well-known Swati Tirunal Tillana in the raga Dhanashree (also known as Abheri) in a brisk fashion. (I had learnt this Tillana from my guru Param Thillairajah at Sydney and we sang this at the Sydney Murugan temple performance and at Melbourne.  You can read my memories of my guru who passed away last year here, here and here)

I had earlier listened to Anil at the Max Mueller Bhavan recently when he played classical western music but today he was equally adept at carnatic music.  His introductions to the individual songs was bang on and he was quick on the uptake when there were some slight disturbances on the mike as well.

When I met SG after the event and asked him about the difference between Dharmavathi and Madhuvanthi (its equivalent in hindustani music), he quickly and clearly explained it with an instant short demo.  I think he can deliver led-dems as well (if he is not doing so already).  (A part review of SG’s recent concert at Bharat Kalachar can be read here)

What a wonderful way to spend a sunday morning?  Thank you www.sabhash.com and Tchaikovsky Music Club for the opportunity.